Mamma Mia! Cafe & Pizzeria

4.7 ( 180 reviews )
$10–20
318 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY 12553, United States
+1 845-568-3375

Mamma Mia! Cafe & Pizzeria, located at 318 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY, is a gem in the realm of pizza restaurants. Customers rave about the welcoming atmosphere and exceptional service provided by the owner and staff. Olivia Figueroa shared a heartfelt experience, noting the care that went into creating a special heart-shaped pizza for her sister's birthday, highlighting the cafe's commitment to personalized service. Many patrons, such as 'Customer A', note the warmth of the environment and the delicious menu offerings.

The food consistently delights, with reviews praising dishes like the personal trio stromboli—described as the best ever—paired with marinara sauce. The bacon cheese fries topped with chipotle sauce are another crowd favorite, offering a perfect balance of flavor and texture. Even adventurous eaters appreciate the flavorful burgers, with options like the Windsor burger drawing compliments for their hearty and satisfying portions.

Mamma Mia! stands out not just for the food but for fostering a sense of community where customers feel valued. Whether dining in or ordering out, this cafe ensures a delightful culinary experience that keeps patrons returning time and again.

Reviews For Mamma Mia! Cafe & Pizzeria

Olivia Figueroa
Jul 4,2025
Ok I personally haven't been there yet because I live out of state, but I ordered a heart shaped Pie for my sisters birthday who lives near by and asked them to make it special for her and to write a note inside the box from me, and they did exactly that. And I'm so sorry I didn't get the lady on the phone name, but she was more than accommodating to my request and completely understood the feeling of missing family. My sister loved the pizza and it made her day. Thank you so much for your work and for being so kind. I will definitely be coming to visit here when I come to town.
A
Jul 2,2025
First time here and it was wonderful! The owner is warm and welcoming, and you can tell she truly cares about her cafe and customers. My husband and I enjoyed a delicious lunch with flavorful iced teas. We’ll definitely be back for more. 10/10!
vert.
Jun 28,2025
I’ve been to this place many times and I’ve never been disappointed! I ordered a personal trio stromboli and it must’ve been the best I’ve ever had! It was very well cooked and goes really well with the marinara sauce. The burgers are also very tasty, such as the tavern and the Windsor burger and even the bacon cheeseburger (the nutty hog if you are brave enough). The meat is just how I like it and fills me up real quick! Overall, my experience at this place is extremely well and I’d definitely recommend mamma Mia cafe for anyone who ever has the munchies.
Charlie Roberts
May 7,2025
I ordered from them on GrubHub two days in a row as the food was so good! The bacon cheese fries were out of this world with the chipotle sauce and the seasoning on the fries. Then they had the tasty cheese bacon and onions. The turkey club wrap was a good size and the lettuce tomato all tasted fresh!
William Tiffer (William Tiffer)
Apr 28,2025
I'm so glad I was actually greeted nicely by the employees there. Very kind to me. And the pizza was good as well. They have won my loyalty.
Caryn
Apr 14,2025
This amazing special was amazing. I love coming here. I have never had a bad meal.
Leza Fahn
Apr 1,2025
I had an absolutely incredible experience! The atmosphere was warm and inviting, the service was attentive and friendly, and everything was thoughtfully done. The turkey apple panini was amazing and so was the macaroni salad. You can tell they genuinely care about their customers and the quality of what they serve. I can’t wait to return and would recommend this place to anyone looking for a standout experience! The Shake and Grind
Matthew Macri
Mar 23,2025
The team over at Mamma Mia always goes above and beyond. On my wife's birthday a few weeks ago we ordered delivery from here, one of our local favorites. We had just gotten home from a long, exhausting travel day and she wanted something we know to be consistently great. When the order arrived, it was missing a full pizza and 2 desserts. The delivery person (from a delivery app, not affiliated with Mamma Mia) told us they were not given a pizza or desserts with the rest of the order, which turned out to not be true. After calling Mamma Mia, they not only fixed the situation by driving over the pizza and desserts free of charge, but one of the owners dropped them off, with a bonus birthday dessert as an apology for the inconvenience. It was totally unnecessary since we understood the mixup, but it made for a great birthday treat. We've continued to be loyal customers ever since, ordering by phone, instead of delivery app. Thanks, Mamma Mia!

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Eagle Tavern
(332 review)
Eagle Tavern
  • Main St, Dearborn, MI 48124, United States
American restaurant
+1 313-982-6001
Main Road Biscuit Co.
(660 review)
Main Road Biscuit Co.
  • 1601 Main Rd, Jamesport, NY 11947, United States
Brunch restaurant
+1 631-779-3463
City Pizza & Sub Co.
(248 review)
City Pizza & Sub Co.
  • 300 E Baltimore St, Wilmington, IL 60481, United States
pizza restaurant
+1 815-450-9008
Scooter's World Famous Dawg House
(2272 review)
Scooter's World Famous Dawg House
  • 9600 Blackbrook Rd, Mentor, OH 44060, United States
hot dog restaurant
+1 440-354-8480
Southern Social Eatery @ The OC
(442 review)
Southern Social Eatery @ The OC
  • 680 Innovation Blvd, Forney, TX 75126, United States
Takeout restaurant
+1 972-357-7681
Empire Tacos
(365 review)
Empire Tacos
  • 219 W Main St, Mulvane, KS 67110, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 316-358-7694
Channa Kitchen
(139 review)
Channa Kitchen
  • 2940 Harriet Ave, Minneapolis, MN 55408, United States
caribbean restaurant
+1 612-568-3342
Big Kahuna Wings - Farragut
(954 review)
Big Kahuna Wings - Farragut
  • 12828 Kingston Pike, Knoxville, TN 37934, United States
Chicken wings restaurant
+1 865-288-7891
Om Indian Cuisine
(499 review)
Om Indian Cuisine
  • 190 River Rd Unit 5, Portage la Prairie, MB R1N 3V6, Canada
Indian restaurant
+1 204-240-2442
K Brew
(296 review)
K Brew
  • 1000 Ebenezer Rd, Knoxville, TN 37923, United States
Coffee shop
+1 865-248-3137